Operator-Led Due Diligence: What the QofE Misses in Trades Businesses
Why dispatch boards, callback rates, and technician productivity belong in every diligence file — and how to underwrite them.
When most buyers diligence a trades or service business, they get a Quality of Earnings report, a tax review, a customer concentration cut, and call it done. That's table stakes — and it's also where most acquisitions quietly start to underperform.
A QofE will tell you the EBITDA is real. It won't tell you whether the EBITDA is *durable*. In a service business, durability lives in operating mechanics that don't show up on the income statement.
What we actually look at
- Dispatch board and route density. Are technicians running tight, profitable routes — or burning two hours a day in the truck? Density determines unit economics in a way no broker deck will surface.
- Callback rate by technician and by job type. A 4% callback rate vs. 12% is the difference between a healthy service business and a slow margin leak. We pull the work order data and slice it ourselves.
- Technician productivity and tenure. Revenue per tech, billable hours per day, and average tenure tell you everything about whether the business has built a team — or just rented one.
- Customer file cleanliness. Maintenance agreements should map cleanly to recurring revenue. If they don't, the "recurring" line is fiction.
- Supplier terms and rebate stacks. A surprising amount of trades EBITDA hides in supplier rebates that may or may not transfer at close.
Why it matters
Every one of these levers moves post-close performance more than the headline multiple ever will. We've watched buyers pay a fair price for a great-looking business and lose 30% of EBITDA in the first eighteen months because they underwrote the spreadsheet, not the operation.
That's the gap operator-led diligence closes.